|

What began as EDP Audit, then came to be known as IS Audit, and
is now known as IT Audit. In the early days of EDP Audit the mission
was to bring management attention and control to the technically
oriented world of data processing. In those days the EDP Auditors
were the management control generalists who understood the basics
of information systems, and the Data Processing Managers were frequently
the technicians who unfortunately often did not understand the basics
of business management. The primary goal of the EDP Audit pioneers
was to focus senior management attention on the new business risks
inherent in information systems, and to establish appropriate control
measures. Their success is evident in the establishment of positions
dedicated to computer security, quality assurance, and contingency
planning within contemporary information technology functions.

Advances in technology gave the IS Auditors more to be concerned
about - as basic management controls were now dependent on implementation
of specific technical controls, and the computing environment became
much more complex. And as technology became more "technical"
- IS Auditors became convinced that they should be "technical"
as well, and began the perpetual struggle to try to keep up with
technology advances. Today's IT Auditors are almost never a one
man team. Support staff & peripheral softwares specialized for
various audit functions have given rise to the Audit Department
in companies. Technology issues keep changing by the day as more
powerful applications make business processes completely dependant
on these systems. Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) is a case in
point.
Software piracy has moved on from illegally copying discs &
distributing to downloading from the Internet. Auditing software
licensing in an organization was not an easy task even in the days
when license papers were checked with the number of actual licensed
copies of the software running in the organization. Today there
may not be any license papers to cross check. When softwares started
being available for download from websites on the Internet, auditors
moved on from proper policies for CD drive & floppy disc access
to writing Internet policies that would prevent employees from downloading
& installing software from websites. Close to its heels came
file sharing applications. Napster is a wildly popular peer-to-peer
service that allows users to search for and download particular
music tracks stored on computers of other users. Although Napster
(free service) has been stopped after it lost a copyright legal
battle with the music industry, there has always been a P2P software
to fill the void. Aimster, iMesh, Audiogalaxy & now Kazaa have
all risen in popularity, one after the other. Now, not only music,
but just about any file can be shared using these applications.
Software inventory checking needs to become a normal management
practice, using any of the wide range of products available such
as Centennial Discovery or LANAuditor
Various organizations have guidelines issued for IT auditors. Five
recently issued documents are the result of continuing efforts to
define, assess, report on, and improve internal control. They are:
the Information Systems Audit and Control Foundation's COBIT (Control
Objectives for Information and related Technology), the Institute
of Internal Auditors Research Foundation's Systems Auditability
and Control (SAC), the Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of
the Treadway Commission's Internal Control - Integrated Framework
(COSO), and the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants'
Consideration of the Internal Control Structure in a Financial Statement
Audit (SAS 55), as amended by Consideration of Internal Control
in a Financial Statement Audit: An Amendment to SAS 55 (SAS 78).
|
Comparison of Control
Concepts
|
| |
COBIT |
SAC |
COSO |
SASs 55/78 |
| Primary Audience |
Management, users, information system
auditors |
Internal Auditors |
Management |
External Auditors |
| IC viewed as a |
Set of processes including policies,
procedures, practices, and organizational structures |
Set of processes, subsystems, and
people |
Process |
Process |
| IC Objectives organizational |
Effective & efficient operations
Confidentiality, Integrity and availability of information
Reliable financial reporting
Compliance with laws & regs |
Effective & efficient operations
Reliable financial reporting
Compliance with laws & regs |
Effective & efficient operations
Reliable financial reporting
Compliance with laws & regs |
Reliable financial reporting
Effective & efficient operations
Compliance with laws & regs |
| Components or Domains |
Domains: |
Components: |
Components: |
Components: |
| |
Planning and organization
Acquisition and implementation
Delivery and support
Monitoring |
Control Environment
Manual & Automated
Systems Control Procedures |
Control Environment
Risk Management Control
Activities Information & Communication Monitoring |
Control Environment Risk
Assessment Control
Activities Information & Communication Monitoring |
| Focus |
Information Technology |
Information Technology |
Overall Entity |
Financial Statement |
| IC Effectiveness Evaluated |
For a period of time |
For a period of time |
At a point in time |
For a period of time |
| Responsibility for IC System |
Management |
Management |
Management |
Management |
| Size |
187 pages in four documents |
1193 pages in 12 modules |
353 pages in four volumes |
63 pages in two documents |
COBIT audit guidelines have become a standard in the
industry. Based on analysis of the information technology infrastructure
library (ITIL) IT management practices, a UK document, COBIT classifies
IT processes into four domains. These four domains are (1) planning
and organization, (2) acquisition and implementation, (3) delivery
and support and (4) monitoring. The natural grouping of processes
into domains is often confirmed as responsibility domains in an
organizational structure and follows the management cycle or life
cycle applicable to IT processes in any IT environment. The Exhibit
illustrates the relationship between IT resources and the four IT
process domains and lists 34 IT processes and 7 Information Criteria.
Exhibit
1.0 (click to open new window)
Certification in IT audit is widely accepted today as an important
qualification for IT auditors. Although they do not guarantee that
the auditor will be superior to an auditor who is not certified,
it can be a important criteria while deciding on an auditor for
your organization. Certified Information Systems Auditor (CISA)
is a certification awarded by the Information Systems Audit and
Control Association (ISACA), which was formed in 1969 to meet the
unique, diverse and high technology needs of the burgeoning IT field.
In an industry in which progress is measured in nano-seconds, ISACA
has moved with agility and speed to bridge the needs of the international
business community and the IT controls profession. The Information
Systems Audit and Control Association is a leading global professional
organisation representing individuals in more than 100 countries.
Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP) is
awarded by The International Information Systems Security Certification
Consortium, Inc. The (ISC)2 Inc. was established in mid-1989. This
non-profit organization creates and administers a certification
program for information security professionals & has professionals
in 31 countries.
Due to the dynamic nature of information technology, the need arises
to continuously redefine audit, control and security requirements
and processes. Certifications like the above are geared to keep
pace with these IT needs. To meet the needs of management, audit
committees, government regulators, and other constituents, CISAs
are required to remain current with new practices, trends and technology.
This is accomplished through mandatory compliance with the CISA
continuing education policy.
Personal Professional Development
· ISACA professional education activities and meetings
· Non-ISACA professional education activities and meetings
· Self-study courses
· Vendor sales/marketing presentations
Contributions to the Profession
· Teaching/lecturing/presenting
· Publication of articles, monographs and books.
· CISA question development and review
· Passing related professional examinations
· ISACA and Information Systems Audit and Control Foundation
(ISACF) Board/Committee work
· Contributions to the IS audit and control profession
To retain certification, CISSPs too must obtain 120 Continuing
Professional Education (CPE) credits over three years. CPE credits
are earned by performing activities largely related to the information
systems security profession including, but not limited to, the following:
· Educational courses or seminar attendance
· Security conference attendance
· Association chapter membership and meeting attendance
· Vendor presentations
· University/college course completion
· Providing security training
· Publishing security articles or books
· Serving on industry boards
· Self-study
· Volunteer work, including serving on (ISC)2 volunteer committees
IT Audit teams are difficult to build. The skill sets required have
been traditionally hard to find, hence demand a premium. Even companies
with large internal IT audit departments have a hard time keeping
their staff trained on all current and emerging technologies. The
right co-sourcing/outsourcing decision can give an organization
an edge over competitors, which goes much beyond than just cost
savings.
your
comments on the article
contact
the author
Share the wealth!
If you know colleagues who would be interested in this newsletter,
please direct them to http://www.webizus.com/newsletter.html
To unsubscribe from the monthly newsletter, click
on the link below to e-mail your request to us. YOU WILL RECEIVE
NO FURTHER NEWSLETTERS from Webizus Technologies if you do.
newsletter@webizus.com?subject=unsubscribe
Webizus takes your privacy seriously. To learn more
about Webizus' use of personal information, please read our Privacy
Policy at http://www.webizus.com/privacy.html
Disclaimer:
Webizus through the content published makes no warranties or guarantees
about the products/ services represented or about the articles presented
in the newsletter. The articles by various authors are entirely
their own opinion. Webizus holds no responsibility to any damage
or loss incurred in any form to any person or organization due to
the publication of any of the issues.
Copyright ©1999-2002, Webizus Technologies, All
Rights Reserved.
For more information mail us on info@webizus.com
Contact us today for a demonstration of how we can
cut down your costs and improve your business:
Email us at: info@webizus.com
or call us at +91-9821634476 / +91-22-55910132
Download
our corporate profile
|